War brings out the worst in both sides.

The argument of a “Just War” aside, one can’t help but be appalled by displays of man’s inhumanity to man in situations of (prolonged) armed conflict.

Naisip ko ito after I finished reading this nice book  — “nice” hindi dahil sa kwento, kasi giyera nga siya, which is the opposite of nice… but for the way it captures the emotions connected with war, emotions from both sides of the line.

That book is Vasily Grossman‘s “A Writer at War,” edited and translated from the original by Antony Beevor and Luba Vinogradova.

Btw, this was lent to me by a dear friend and colleague, who is a fellow “booksale addict” (halata ba sa presyo nung libro? hehe)

What’s striking about the book, apart from the compelling story-telling, were the circumstances surrounding the author himself.

First off, Grossman, although a very talented correspondent, was a Ukrainian Jew — something very inconvenient to be in Stalin‘s Soviet Union, to say the least.

Second, due to events entirely out of his control, Grossman found himself witnessing the initial crushing defeats and subsequent overwhelming triumphs of the Red Army, ordered as he was by his superiors in the Soviet military newspaper, Krasnaya Zvezda (Red Star), to stay very close to the frontlines of the Eastern Front.

Needless to say, I was often at the edge of my seat while reading the book… wait, make that “at the edge of the kutson” (masarap kasing magbasa habang nakahilata sa kama. hehehe…)

Maraming seryosong usapin ang inihatag ng librong ito. Pero ang  pinaka-mahalaga marahil, at ito rin (yata) ang naging realisasyon ni Grossman sa dulo, ay ang sumusunod:

Nasa tama ka man o nasa mali, ang barbarismo ay barbarismo pa din. Kahit sa kalaban ito gawin, o kahit kasama ang gumagawa; dulot man ng poot at ng pagnanais na ipaghiganti ang mga mahal sa buhay … wala pa ring puwang sa mundo ang ganitong klaseng pag-uugali.

Saktong-sakto sa mga kaganapan sa Maguindanao nitong nakaraang araw 😦

Advertisements
War brings out the worst in both sides.

2 thoughts on “War brings out the worst in both sides.

  1. songcompiler ay nagsasabing:

    alam mo pare di ako ganun ka hilig sa gera etc.. pero pag may nakikita q pinapanuod q nmn if nasa mood aq.
    Pero nung nabasa ko yung tagalog quote mo naalala ko lang yung sa naruto yung nag uusap na sila ni PAIN habang nakapako si naruo nag uusap kc sila 2nkol sa gantihan at digmaan
    naalala q lng

    you are just working for your own justice and i’m doing mine

    resulta nito hatred at tpos pag gumanti yung isa gaganti rin yung isa at yun di matatapos dahil nagkaron na ng hatred
    and then endless war..

    Hmm hope na share ko ng maayus yung thought ko d2 =P

    Taroogs
    — salamat sa pag-share, kapatid. sabi nga ng ibang henyo sa tabi-tabi… anime mirrors society daw 😀

Mag-iwan ng Tugon

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Baguhin )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Baguhin )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Baguhin )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Baguhin )

Connecting to %s